A Heartfelt Journey into Avonlea: Review of Anne of Green Gables: A Graphic Novel by Mariah Marsden

Introduction: A Timeless Tale Reimagined

Few literary characters have captured hearts as enduringly as Anne Shirley, the fiery-haired, endlessly imaginative orphan from Lucy Maud Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables. Now, Mariah Marsden and illustrator Brenna Thummler bring Anne’s world to life in a stunning graphic novel adaptation that preserves the charm of the original while offering a fresh, visually immersive experience.

Whether you’re a longtime fan of Avonlea or a newcomer to Anne’s adventures, this adaptation is a treasure. But does it do justice to Montgomery’s beloved classic? Let’s dive deep into the pages of Anne of Green Gables: A Graphic Novel and explore its magic, its artistry, and its emotional resonance.

Plot Summary: A Girl, a Home, and a World of Imagination

For those unfamiliar with the story, Anne of Green Gables follows the misadventures of Anne Shirley, an orphan mistakenly sent to live with siblings Marilla and Matthew Cuthbert, who had intended to adopt a boy to help on their farm, Green Gables. Instead, they receive Anne—a talkative, dreamy, and fiercely intelligent girl who turns their quiet lives upside down.

The graphic novel faithfully condenses the original novel’s key moments:

  • Anne’s arrival in Avonlea and her immediate bond with the landscape
  • Her fiery temper, poetic musings, and dramatic mishaps (who could forget the infamous raspberry cordial incident?)
  • Her academic rivalry-turned-friendship with Gilbert Blythe
  • Her deep, evolving relationships with Marilla and Matthew

Marsden’s adaptation streamlines the narrative without losing its emotional core, making it accessible for younger readers while still satisfying longtime fans.

Character Analysis: Anne, Marilla, and the Soul of Green Gables

Anne Shirley: Imagination Incarnate

Anne is a character who wears her heart on her sleeve. Her boundless imagination, quick temper, and relentless optimism make her unforgettable. The graphic novel captures her essence beautifully—her expressive face, her dramatic gestures, and the way she sees magic in the ordinary.

Marilla & Matthew Cuthbert: The Reluctant Guardians

Marilla’s stern exterior hides deep affection, and Matthew’s quiet kindness is Anne’s anchor. The adaptation does justice to their slow, heartfelt acceptance of Anne, showing how she reshapes their lives.

Gilbert Blythe: The Rival with a Heart

Gilbert’s arc—from teasing adversary to respectful friend—is condensed but impactful. His presence adds depth to Anne’s journey, hinting at future developments for those who know the series.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: A Visual Feast

Marsden’s adaptation skillfully balances Montgomery’s lyrical prose with the graphic novel format. The dialogue retains Anne’s signature verbosity while ensuring readability. The real star, however, is Brenna Thummler’s artwork—soft watercolors, expressive character designs, and lush landscapes that make Avonlea feel alive.

The pacing is brisk but never rushed, making it ideal for reluctant readers or those new to Anne’s world. Some purists might miss Montgomery’s detailed descriptions, but the visuals compensate beautifully.

Themes & Deeper Meanings: Belonging, Growth, and Kindred Spirits

At its core, Anne of Green Gables is about finding home in unexpected places. The graphic novel preserves these themes:

  • Belonging: Anne’s journey from orphan to cherished daughter
  • Imagination as Survival: Her creativity helps her cope with hardship
  • Forgiveness & Growth: Her clashes with others (and herself) teach empathy

The adaptation also subtly highlights female independence, particularly through Marilla’s quiet strength and Anne’s refusal to conform.

Personal Reading Experience: Why This Adaptation Resonates

Reading this graphic novel felt like revisiting an old friend. The artwork brought new warmth to familiar scenes—Anne naming the Snow Queen tree, her tearful goodbye to Matthew, her triumphant academic achievements. I laughed at her theatrics and teared up at the tender moments.

For new readers, this is a perfect introduction. For fans, it’s a nostalgic love letter.

Comparison to Other Adaptations & Genre Works

Compared to other graphic novel adaptations of classics (like Pride and Prejudice or The Giver), this one stands out for its emotional authenticity and visual storytelling. It doesn’t replace the original but complements it, much like the 1985 TV miniseries did.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Gorgeous artwork that enhances the story
✅ Faithful yet concise adaptation
✅ Perfect for middle-grade readers and nostalgic adults

Weaknesses:

❌ Some secondary characters (like Diana) feel slightly underdeveloped
❌ A few iconic scenes are shortened (e.g., Anne’s early school struggles)

Target Audience: Who Should Read This?

  • Young readers (8-12) discovering Anne for the first time
  • Graphic novel enthusiasts who love classic adaptations
  • Longtime fans wanting a fresh take
  • Educators & parents looking for engaging literary introductions

Memorable Quotes & Passages

While the graphic novel naturally relies on visuals, some lines still shine:

  • “Kindred spirits are not so scarce as I used to think.”
  • “Tomorrow is always fresh, with no mistakes in it.”

Cultural & Historical Context

Montgomery’s original (1908) reflected early 20th-century rural Canada. This adaptation keeps the setting intact while making it visually timeless.

Final Verdict: A Must-Read for Anne Fans

Anne of Green Gables: A Graphic Novel is a triumph—a loving, visually stunning retelling that honors Montgomery’s legacy while standing on its own. Whether you’re revisiting Avonlea or stepping into it for the first time, this book is a treasure.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • How does the graphic novel format change your experience of Anne’s story?
  • Which character do you relate to most—Anne, Marilla, or Matthew?
  • If you’ve read the original, what scenes did you miss in this version?

Let’s chat in the comments—I’d love to hear your thoughts! 📚💬

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.