A Delightfully Wholesome Guide to Feelings: Review of To Fart Or Not To Fart by Asaf Shani

Introduction: Why This Book Stands Out

Parenting is full of teachable moments, and few things are as universally relatable—or as hilariously awkward—as discussing bodily functions and emotions with young children. To Fart Or Not To Fart: A Kids Book on Feelings by Asaf Shani tackles this delicate subject with humor, warmth, and a surprising amount of depth. Part of The Life Skills Series, this book isn’t just about giggles (though there are plenty); it’s a clever tool for helping preschoolers navigate social norms, self-awareness, and emotional intelligence.

If you’ve ever struggled to explain why burping at the dinner table isn’t polite or why holding in a fart might not always be the best idea, this book is a godsend. But does it live up to its promise? Let’s dive in.

Plot Summary: A Playful Lesson in Manners & Emotions

The story follows a young child (gender-neutral, making it relatable for all kids) as they grapple with a very pressing dilemma: Should I fart in public? Through a series of amusing scenarios—classroom settings, playdates, family dinners—the book explores the consequences of acting (or not acting) on bodily urges.

Without spoiling the fun, the narrative doesn’t just settle for a simple “don’t do it” message. Instead, it encourages kids to think about context—when is it okay to let one rip (maybe at home with close family) and when it might be better to excuse themselves? Along the way, the book also touches on related themes like embarrassment, honesty, and self-control.

Character Analysis: Relatable & Expressive

The protagonist is intentionally designed to be an everychild—no specific name, no overly detailed features—which makes it easy for young readers to project themselves into the story. The supporting characters (parents, teachers, friends) react in exaggerated but realistic ways, reinforcing social cues without being preachy.

What stands out is how the book validates the child’s feelings. Instead of shaming natural bodily functions, it acknowledges them as normal while gently guiding kids toward polite behavior. This balance is crucial for building self-esteem alongside manners.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Simple Yet Effective

Shani’s writing is straightforward but engaging, with short sentences and rhythmic pacing perfect for ages 3–5. The humor is slapstick but never crude, making it a hit with kids while keeping parents entertained.

The illustrations (bright, expressive, and full of playful details) complement the text beautifully. Visual cues help reinforce the message—like a character’s wide-eyed shock or a parent’s patient smile—making it accessible even for pre-readers.

Thematic Exploration: More Than Just Farts

Beneath the silliness, To Fart Or Not To Fart is really about:

  • Emotional Awareness: Recognizing how actions affect others.
  • Contextual Understanding: Learning that different settings call for different behaviors.
  • Self-Regulation: Practicing patience and impulse control.

It’s a subtle introduction to empathy, wrapped in a topic kids find endlessly funny.

Personal Reading Experience: Laughter & Learning

Reading this with my 4-year-old was a riot. The first time we got to the page where the child debates letting one loose in class, she burst into giggles—but then paused and asked, “Would the teacher be mad?” That spark of critical thinking is exactly what the book aims for.

It also opened up conversations about other “unspoken rules” (like covering your mouth when you cough), making it a springboard for broader discussions.

Comparison to Other Books in the Genre

Most manners books for preschoolers (Germs Are Not for Sharing, Excuse Me!) take a more serious tone. To Fart Or Not To Fart stands out by using humor to disarm resistance—kids are more receptive when they’re laughing.

It’s also more nuanced than Everyone Poops (which normalizes bodily functions but doesn’t address etiquette). Shani’s book strikes a rare balance between acceptance and guidance.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

  • Humor that works for kids and adults
  • Non-shaming approach to natural behaviors
  • Prompts meaningful parent-child discussions
  • Inclusive, gender-neutral protagonist

Weaknesses:

  • Might be too silly for some parents (if you prefer strict etiquette books, this isn’t it)
  • Limited plot complexity (but that’s expected for the age group)

Target Audience: Who Should Read This?

Perfect for:

  • Parents of 3–5-year-olds navigating manners and emotions
  • Preschool teachers looking for a lighthearted way to discuss rules
  • Kids who love funny stories but need subtle life lessons

Not ideal for:

  • Older kids (the humor may feel too juvenile past kindergarten)
  • Families seeking a strictly serious tone

Memorable Quotes & Passages

“Sometimes a fart wants out… but is now the right time?”

“At home, it’s just funny. At school? Maybe not so much.”

The simplicity of these lines makes them stick—kids remember them long after reading.

Cultural Context: Why This Book Matters

In an era where children’s books increasingly focus on emotional intelligence, To Fart Or Not To Fart fills a unique niche. It doesn’t just teach manners; it helps kids understand why they matter—without stifling their natural curiosity.

Final Verdict: A Must-Have for Playful Parenting

This book is a gem—funny, thoughtful, and surprisingly profound in its simplicity. It doesn’t just tell kids what to do; it helps them think about their actions. Whether you’re dealing with fart jokes at the dinner table or teaching empathy, To Fart Or Not To Fart is a tool you’ll reach for again and again.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Parents & Kids:

  1. When do you think it’s okay to fart loudly?
  2. How would you feel if someone farted next to you?
  3. What other “rules” should we talk about?

Have you read this book? Share your funniest parenting moments in the comments!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.