A Gentle Guide Through Life’s Greatest Mystery: Review of Lifetimes: The Beautiful Way to Explain Death to Children by Bryan Mellonie

Introduction: A Book That Speaks to the Heart

Death is an inevitable part of life, yet explaining it to children remains one of the most daunting tasks for parents, caregivers, and educators. How do we convey such a profound concept in a way that is honest, gentle, and comforting? Bryan Mellonie’s Lifetimes: The Beautiful Way to Explain Death to Children is a tender, beautifully illustrated book that does just that—offering a simple yet profound way to help children understand the natural cycle of life and death.

First published in 1983, this timeless classic remains one of the most recommended books for discussing death with young readers. But does it hold up decades later? And how does it compare to other books in the genre? In this in-depth review, I’ll explore the book’s structure, themes, emotional impact, and why it continues to resonate with families worldwide.

Plot Summary: A Gentle Journey Through Life’s Cycle

Lifetimes does not follow a traditional narrative but instead presents a series of observations about life and death in nature. The book begins by explaining that all living things—plants, animals, and people—have a beginning, a middle, and an end. Using straightforward language, Mellonie describes how lifetimes vary in length: a butterfly may live for only a few weeks, while a tree might stand for hundreds of years.

The book then gently transitions to human life, acknowledging that people, too, have lifetimes that eventually come to an end. What makes this book so special is its matter-of-fact yet compassionate tone. There is no sugarcoating, no euphemisms—just a clear, reassuring explanation that death is a natural part of existence.

Robert Ingpen’s soft, evocative illustrations complement the text beautifully, depicting scenes of nature and human life in a way that feels both peaceful and profound.

Character Analysis & Development: A Universal Perspective

Since Lifetimes is not a storybook with characters, its “characters” are the living things it describes—flowers, fish, birds, and people. The book treats each with equal respect, reinforcing the idea that all life is interconnected.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Simplicity with Profound Depth

Mellonie’s writing is deceptively simple. Each sentence is carefully crafted to be accessible to young readers while still carrying deep meaning. The book avoids abstract metaphors (like “Grandma went to sleep”) that might confuse children, opting instead for clarity:

“There is a beginning and an ending for everything that is alive. In between is living.”

This directness is one of the book’s greatest strengths. It doesn’t shy away from the truth but presents it in a way that feels safe and reassuring. The pacing is slow and deliberate, allowing each idea to settle before moving to the next.

Robert Ingpen’s illustrations enhance the text with warmth and subtlety. His soft watercolors depict life’s fleeting beauty—a wilting flower, a bird in flight, an elderly person smiling—without ever feeling morbid.

Thematic Exploration: Life, Death, and the Beauty in Between

At its core, Lifetimes is about acceptance. It teaches children (and reminds adults) that:

  1. Death is natural – Just as flowers bloom and fade, so do all living things.
  2. Life is precious – Because lifetimes are finite, we should cherish the time we have.
  3. Grief is okay – The book validates sadness while offering comfort in nature’s rhythms.

Unlike some children’s books that focus solely on loss, Lifetimes balances sorrow with celebration. It doesn’t just explain death—it celebrates life.

Personal Reading Experience: Why This Book Stays with You

I first read Lifetimes after the passing of a family pet, searching for a way to explain it to my young niece. What struck me was how calm and unafraid she was after reading it. Instead of fearing death, she saw it as part of a bigger picture—something that happens to all living things.

As an adult, I found myself moved by its simplicity. In a world that often avoids talking about death, this book faces it head-on with grace. It doesn’t offer platitudes or false comfort; it offers truth, and there’s something deeply comforting in that honesty.

Comparison to Other Books in the Genre

Several other children’s books tackle death, but Lifetimes stands out for its universal approach.

  • The Invisible String by Patrice Karst focuses on emotional connections beyond death.
  • The Goodbye Book by Todd Parr deals with grief in a more abstract way.
  • The Fall of Freddie the Leaf by Leo Buscaglia uses a leaf’s life cycle as a metaphor.

While these are all excellent, Lifetimes is unique in its directness. It doesn’t rely on fantasy or metaphor—it simply states facts in a way that feels both gentle and empowering.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Clear, honest language – No confusing euphemisms.
✅ Beautiful illustrations – Soft and soothing, perfect for sensitive topics.
✅ Universal approach – Applies to pets, people, and nature.
✅ Timeless message – Just as relevant today as in 1983.

Minor Weaknesses:

❌ May feel too brief – Some parents might want more discussion prompts.
❌ Not religious – Families seeking a faith-based perspective may need to supplement.

Target Audience: Who Should Read This Book?

Lifetimes is ideal for:

  • Children ages 4-10 – Simple enough for preschoolers, profound enough for older kids.
  • Parents & caregivers – A helpful tool for difficult conversations.
  • Educators & counselors – Useful in classrooms or therapy settings.

It’s especially valuable for families dealing with:

  • The death of a pet
  • The loss of a grandparent or loved one
  • Questions about mortality

Memorable Quotes & Passages

“For all living things, there is a beginning, a living, and an ending. That is the way it is.”

“No matter how long they last, lifetimes are really all the same. They have beginnings, and endings, and there is living in between.”

These lines capture the book’s essence—simple, profound, and deeply reassuring.

Cultural & Historical Context

Published in the early 1980s, Lifetimes arrived during a time when death education for children was still evolving. Before this, many books either avoided the subject entirely or relied heavily on religious explanations. Mellonie’s secular, nature-based approach was groundbreaking—and remains refreshingly inclusive today.

Final Thoughts: A Book Every Family Should Have

Lifetimes is more than a children’s book—it’s a gentle guide for anyone struggling to explain life’s hardest truth. Its honesty, warmth, and simplicity make it a timeless resource. Whether you’re a parent, teacher, or simply someone looking for comfort, this book offers wisdom that lingers long after the last page.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • How did you first learn about death as a child?
  • Do you think directness or metaphor works better when explaining death to kids?
  • What other books have helped you discuss tough topics with children?

I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.