Book Review: Scythe (1) (Arc of a Scythe)
A Masterpiece of Morality and Mortality: A Comprehensive Review of Scythe by Neal Shusterman
Introduction: A World Without Death—But at What Cost?
Imagine a world where humanity has conquered death. No disease, no aging, no accidents—just an endless existence governed by an all-knowing AI called the Thunderhead. Sounds like utopia, right? But in Scythe, the first book in Neal Shusterman’s Arc of a Scythe trilogy, this “perfect” world comes with a chilling caveat: to prevent overpopulation, a select few—known as Scythes—must “glean” (a euphemism for kill) people at random.
This isn’t just another dystopian novel. Scythe is a philosophical deep dive into power, ethics, and what it truly means to be human. If you love thought-provoking sci-fi with razor-sharp social commentary, this book is for you.
🔗 Get the Book: Amazon
Plot Summary: A Deadly Apprenticeship
The story follows two teenagers, Citra Terranova and Rowan Damisch, who are unwillingly chosen as apprentices to Scythe Faraday, a compassionate and methodical killer. Their training thrusts them into a brutal world where they must learn the art of taking lives—ethically, if such a thing is possible.
But not all Scythes share Faraday’s principles. The Scythedom is divided between traditionalists, who see gleaning as a solemn duty, and the “new order,” led by the ruthless Scythe Goddard, who revels in power and spectacle. When Citra and Rowan are pitted against each other in a deadly competition to become the next Scythe, they must navigate moral dilemmas, political intrigue, and their own survival.
Shusterman masterfully balances action with introspection, making Scythe both a page-turner and a meditation on mortality.
Character Analysis: The Weight of the Blade
Citra Terranova – The Reluctant Idealist
Citra is pragmatic, sharp-witted, and fiercely independent. Unlike Rowan, she doesn’t seek glory or power—she’s driven by duty and a deep sense of justice. Her struggle isn’t just about mastering the art of killing; it’s about retaining her humanity in a system designed to strip it away.
Rowan Damisch – The Broken Protector
Rowan is more emotionally vulnerable than Citra, shaped by a past where he failed to protect those he loved. His journey is darker, as he grapples with anger, vengeance, and the seductive allure of power. His arc raises haunting questions: Can someone who kills for a living ever be good?
Scythe Faraday & Scythe Goddard – Two Sides of the Same Coin
Faraday represents the old guard—stoic, principled, and burdened by his role. Goddard, on the other hand, is a charismatic villain who treats gleaning as a performance, embodying corruption in a system meant to be impartial. Their ideological clash drives much of the novel’s tension.
Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Sharp as a Scythe’s Blade
Shusterman’s prose is crisp, immersive, and often poetic. He intersperses the main narrative with journal entries from various Scythes, offering glimpses into their philosophies and the moral decay within the Scythedom. This technique adds depth, making the world feel lived-in and real.
The pacing is deliberate—slower in the beginning to establish the world, then accelerating into a breathless finale. The dialogue crackles with tension, especially in scenes between Citra and Rowan, whose dynamic evolves from rivalry to something far more complex.
Themes & Deeper Meanings: What Does It Mean to Kill (or Live) Forever?
The Ethics of Power
Scythe forces readers to ask: If you had absolute power over life and death, how would you wield it? Faraday believes in mercy and fairness; Goddard sees it as a game. The book doesn’t offer easy answers, making it ripe for discussion.
The Illusion of Utopia
The Thunderhead has eliminated suffering, but at what cost? Without death, do people truly value life? Shusterman critiques complacency, suggesting that struggle and impermanence might be necessary for meaning.
Moral Ambiguity
Neither Citra nor Rowan is purely heroic. Both make morally questionable choices, blurring the line between right and wrong. This gray morality makes them compelling and deeply human.
Personal Reading Experience: A Book That Lingers Like a Ghost
I devoured Scythe in two sittings—it’s that gripping. But what stayed with me weren’t just the twists (of which there are many), but the questions it left echoing in my mind:
- Would I rather live forever or face death?
- Could I take a life if it were “for the greater good”?
- Is absolute power inherently corrupting?
This isn’t just entertainment; it’s a book that demands introspection.
Comparison to Other Works in the Genre
Fans of The Hunger Games will appreciate the high-stakes competition and political intrigue, while readers of Brave New World or The Giver will recognize the dystopian critique of a “perfect” society. However, Scythe stands out for its unique premise and philosophical depth.
Strengths & Minor Weaknesses
Strengths:
✔ Original premise – A fresh take on dystopia.
✔ Complex characters – No one is purely good or evil.
✔ Thought-provoking themes – Goes beyond surface-level action.
Weaknesses:
❌ Slow start – The world-building takes time to settle.
❌ Some underdeveloped side characters – A few feel like plot devices.
Who Should Read This?
- Dystopian fans – If you loved The Hunger Games or Divergent, this is a must-read.
- Philosophy nerds – The ethical dilemmas are meaty and rewarding.
- YA readers who crave depth – This isn’t just a romance disguised as sci-fi.
Memorable Quotes
“The greatest achievement of the human race was not conquering death. It was ending government.” — Scythe Curie
“My greatest wish for humanity is not for peace or comfort or joy. It is that we all still die a little inside every time we witness the death of another.” — Scythe Faraday
Final Verdict: A Cutting-Edge Masterpiece
Scythe is more than a YA dystopian novel—it’s a profound exploration of life, death, and the choices that define us. With its unforgettable characters, razor-sharp prose, and relentless moral questions, it’s a book that will haunt you long after the last page.
If you’re ready to be challenged, thrilled, and utterly absorbed, pick up Scythe today.
🔗 Get the Book: Amazon
Discussion Questions for Readers:
- Would you accept immortality if it meant others had to die to maintain balance?
- Which Scythe’s philosophy (Faraday’s or Goddard’s) do you find more compelling?
- Do you think Citra or Rowan made the “right” choices?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments—I’d love to discuss!
For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.
For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.