The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires: A Heartfelt Review on Creativity and Perseverance

Introduction: A Story That Resonates with Every Maker

Have you ever had a brilliant idea in your head, only to struggle when bringing it to life? The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires is a charming, insightful children’s book that captures the frustration, perseverance, and ultimate triumph of the creative process. With its relatable protagonist, engaging illustrations, and universal themes, this book isn’t just for kids—it’s a reminder for anyone who’s ever faced setbacks while chasing a dream.

Whether you’re a parent looking for a meaningful read-aloud, an educator teaching resilience, or simply a lover of beautifully crafted picture books, Spires’ work delivers humor, heart, and wisdom in equal measure. Let’s dive into why this book stands out in the crowded world of children’s literature.

Plot Summary: When Perfectionism Meets Persistence

The story follows an unnamed young girl (referred to as “a regular girl” in the book) and her trusty canine assistant as she sets out to create the most magnificent thing. She knows exactly how it should look and function—but reality has other plans.

With enthusiasm, she gathers materials and begins building. Yet, despite her best efforts, each attempt falls short of her vision. Frustration mounts, mistakes pile up, and eventually, she quits—only to return with fresh eyes and renewed determination. Without spoiling the ending, let’s just say the resolution is both satisfying and realistic, celebrating the beauty of iteration and imperfection.

Character Analysis: A Relatable Heroine for All Ages

The Determined (But Flawed) Creator

The protagonist is instantly relatable—she’s passionate, imaginative, and human. Her journey mirrors the emotional rollercoaster of any creative endeavor: excitement, frustration, anger, and eventual clarity. Kids will see themselves in her struggles, while adults will nod knowingly at her journey.

The Silent but Supportive Sidekick

Her dog companion is more than just comic relief—he’s a steady presence, offering silent encouragement. His loyalty subtly reinforces the idea that creativity thrives with support, even when things go wrong.

Writing Style & Illustrations: Simple Yet Profound

Ashley Spires’ writing is concise yet impactful, balancing humor with emotional depth. The text is accessible for young readers but layered enough for deeper discussions.

The illustrations—also by Spires—are whimsical yet detailed, enhancing the story’s tone. The girl’s exaggerated expressions perfectly capture her shifting emotions, from determination to despair to triumph. The muted color palette keeps the focus on her journey, while small visual gags (like the dog’s antics) add lightness.

Themes & Deeper Meanings: More Than Just a Kids’ Book

1. The Creative Process Isn’t Linear

This book nails the messy reality of making things. It validates frustration while showing that setbacks are part of the process—something rarely addressed in children’s media.

2. The Power of Taking a Break

When the girl walks away, she gains perspective. It’s a subtle but crucial lesson: sometimes, stepping back is the best way forward.

3. Imperfection Can Be Magnificent

The ending doesn’t promise perfection—it celebrates progress. This message is gold for kids (and adults) who struggle with unrealistic expectations.

Personal Reading Experience: Why This Book Stuck with Me

As someone who’s abandoned half-finished projects in frustration, this book hit home. Reading it with my niece, I saw her eyes light up at the girl’s outbursts—“That’s how I feel when my tower falls!”—and her relief at the ending. It sparked a great conversation about patience and perseverance.

For educators, this is a fantastic tool for growth mindset lessons. For parents, it’s a gentle way to discuss handling disappointment. And for creators? It’s a pep talk in picture-book form.

Comparison to Similar Works

Fans of Rosie Revere, Engineer (Andrea Beaty) or The Dot (Peter H. Reynolds) will love this book’s celebration of creativity. However, The Most Magnificent Thing stands out by focusing on the emotional hurdles of creation—not just the end result.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Authentic portrayal of frustration – Rarely do kids’ books show anger this honestly.
✅ Encourages problem-solving – The girl doesn’t magically succeed; she adapts.
✅ Humor balances the heaviness – The dog’s antics keep the mood light.

Weaknesses:

❌ Minimal text might leave some wanting more – A few more descriptive lines could deepen the emotional beats.
❌ The protagonist’s name isn’t revealed – Some readers might prefer a named character for connection.

Who Should Read This Book?

  • Ages 4–8 (but truly, all ages)
  • Parents & Educators – Perfect for teaching resilience.
  • Creatives & Perfectionists – A reminder that “magnificent” doesn’t mean “flawless.”

Memorable Quotes

“She twists and tweaks and fastens. But the thing isn’t magnificent. Or good. It isn’t even kind-of-sort-of okay. It is all WRONG.”

“Then the girl gets *really, really mad. She quits.”*

Final Verdict: A Must-Read for Makers of All Ages

The Most Magnificent Thing is a deceptively simple book with profound takeaways. It’s funny, heartfelt, and real—a rare gem that speaks to kids and adults. Whether you’re buying it for a child or your inner child, this book is a keeper.

đź”— Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • Have you ever felt like the girl in the story? What helped you keep going?
  • How do you teach kids (or yourself) to handle frustration?
  • What’s your “most magnificent thing” that didn’t turn out as planned?

Drop your thoughts in the comments—I’d love to hear your take!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.