Why Not? A Story About Discovering Our Bright Possibilities by Kobi Yamada – A Thoughtful Review

Introduction: A Book That Challenges the Way We See Possibility

Have you ever felt stuck, unsure of whether to take a leap of faith or stay in your comfort zone? Why Not? A Story About Discovering Our Bright Possibilities by Kobi Yamada is a beautifully crafted book that nudges readers—both young and old—to embrace curiosity, courage, and the endless potential within themselves.

Yamada, best known for his inspirational works like What Do You Do With an Idea? and Trying, delivers another gem that blends whimsical storytelling with profound life lessons. This book isn’t just a children’s story; it’s a gentle yet powerful manifesto for anyone who has ever hesitated before pursuing a dream.

In this review, we’ll explore the book’s plot, characters, themes, and why it stands out in the genre of motivational and philosophical children’s literature.

Plot Summary: A Journey of Curiosity and Courage

Why Not? follows a young protagonist who encounters a mysterious, glowing door in the middle of an ordinary day. The door represents the unknown—something both exciting and intimidating. The child hesitates, wrestling with doubt and fear, but eventually asks the pivotal question: Why not?

Without giving away too much, the story unfolds as the protagonist steps through the door and discovers a world brimming with possibilities. The narrative is simple yet deeply metaphorical, illustrating how taking that first brave step can lead to extraordinary experiences.

The plot is intentionally sparse, allowing the illustrations (by the talented Gabriella Barouch) and the philosophical undertones to shine. It’s a story that encourages readers to reflect on their own “doors”—the opportunities they may have hesitated to explore.

Character Analysis: Every Reader Sees Themselves in the Protagonist

The protagonist is intentionally unnamed and gender-neutral, making it easy for any reader to project themselves into the story. This deliberate ambiguity is one of Yamada’s strengths—it ensures that the message is universal.

The character’s emotional arc is subtle but powerful:

  • Initial Hesitation – Fear of the unknown holds them back.
  • Curiosity Awakens – A shift from “What if it’s bad?” to “What if it’s wonderful?”
  • The Leap of Faith – The moment they choose courage over comfort.

This progression mirrors real-life decision-making, making the book relatable to both children and adults.

Writing Style & Narrative Technique: Simple Words, Deep Impact

Yamada’s writing is minimalist yet evocative. He doesn’t over-explain; instead, he trusts the reader (or listener, in the case of young children) to fill in the emotional gaps. The prose is rhythmic, almost poetic, making it a joy to read aloud.

The narrative technique relies heavily on:

  • Open-Ended Questions – Encouraging self-reflection.
  • Repetition for Emphasis – The phrase “Why not?” becomes a mantra.
  • Show, Don’t Tell – The illustrations carry much of the emotional weight.

Themes & Deeper Meanings: More Than Just a Children’s Book

At its core, Why Not? explores:

  • Fear vs. Curiosity – How often do we let fear dictate our choices?
  • The Power of Perspective – What seems daunting at first may hold unimaginable beauty.
  • Growth Through Uncertainty – Stepping into the unknown is where real growth happens.

These themes resonate far beyond childhood. Adults reading this book may find themselves reflecting on career changes, creative pursuits, or personal risks they’ve avoided.

Personal Reading Experience: Why This Book Stays With You

Reading Why Not? felt like a quiet but profound conversation with myself. As someone who often overthinks decisions, the book’s central question—Why not?—lingered in my mind long after I closed it.

The illustrations by Gabriella Barouch are breathtaking—ethereal and dreamlike, they elevate the text into something magical. One particular spread, where the protagonist steps into a world of floating lanterns and swirling colors, gave me goosebumps.

This isn’t just a book to read once; it’s one to revisit whenever you need a nudge toward bravery.

Comparison to Other Works in the Genre

Yamada’s books (What Do You Do With an Idea?, Maybe, Trying) share a common thread—they encourage readers to embrace possibility. Why Not? stands out for its directness. While What Do You Do With an Idea? is more abstract, Why Not? feels like an actionable next step: Okay, you have an idea… now what’s stopping you?

Fans of Peter H. Reynolds’ The Dot or Oliver Jeffers’ The Incredible Book Eating Boy will appreciate Yamada’s blend of whimsy and wisdom.

Strengths & Minor Weaknesses

Strengths:

✅ Universal Appeal – Works for kids, teens, and adults.
✅ Stunning Artwork – Gabriella Barouch’s illustrations are mesmerizing.
✅ Encourages Self-Reflection – Sparks meaningful conversations.

Minor Weaknesses:

❌ May Feel Too Abstract for Some – Readers who prefer concrete narratives might want more plot.
❌ Short Length – At 44 pages, it’s a quick read (though the depth makes up for it).

Who Should Read This Book?

  • Parents & Educators – A great tool for teaching resilience and curiosity.
  • Creatives & Dreamers – Anyone needing a push to take the next step.
  • Fans of Inspirational Picture Books – If you love The Dot or The Book of Mistakes, this is for you.

Memorable Quotes

“What if, instead of being afraid, I was curious?”

“Why not see where this could lead?”

These lines encapsulate the book’s spirit—turning fear into fuel for exploration.

Final Thoughts: A Book That Asks the Right Question

Why Not? is more than a children’s book; it’s a meditation on courage, curiosity, and the paths we don’t take. Kobi Yamada has crafted a story that lingers, gently urging readers to ask themselves: What doors am I hesitating to open?

If you’re looking for a book that inspires action—whether for yourself or a young reader in your life—this is a must-have.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions for Readers:

  • What’s a “door” you’ve hesitated to walk through?
  • How do you balance fear and curiosity in your life?
  • Would you rather live with regret for trying or regret for not trying?

Let me know your thoughts in the comments—I’d love to hear how this book resonated with you!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.