Just Plain Fancy

This gentle story set in an Amish community introduces young readers to a world of simplicity and farm life through the eyes of two sisters, Naomi and Ruth. When the girls discover an unusual egg and secretly hatch it, they find themselves caring for a chick that is anything but ordinary, testing their commitment to their community's values. Patricia Polacco's rich illustrations and warm storytelling create an accessible window into Amish traditions and the beautiful Pennsylvania countryside. The narrative thoughtfully explores themes of responsibility, curiosity, and the meaning of being "plain" in a community that values humility.

What makes this picture book particularly memorable is how it handles the universal childhood experience of wanting something special while learning about cultural traditions and honesty. Children will relate to the sisters' secret and the dilemma they face when their unusual pet can no longer be hidden. The story provides a wonderful starting point for conversations about different ways of life, acceptance, and how we define what makes something truly valuable. Polacco's signature artwork brings emotional depth to this touching tale about finding beauty in simplicity.